Order your fuel

Welcome to the Bay Shore Fuel Online Ordering Portal. Click here to Order by Gallons or Order by Dollars

Example: For $300 worth, input this amount into our calculator below and we will calculate how many gallons you can receive for that amount.

If you would like to fill your tank and don't know how much you need, please select the 275 Gallons option as this is the typical size for a home heating tank.

If you are paying credit card, we will process a refund within 5-7 business days if there is a remaining credit.

Please note, there is a 10 cent discount if you choose to pay cash.

Cash Purchase

Tank Size Sub-total Tax Total Buy now
50 X $5.299 $264.95 $6.62 $271.57 Order Now
75 X $4.699 $352.43 $8.81 $361.24 Order Now
100 X $4.549 $454.90 $11.37 $466.27 Order Now
125 X $4.549 $568.63 $14.22 $582.85 Order Now
150 X $4.499 $674.85 $16.87 $691.72 Order Now
175 X $4.499 $787.33 $19.68 $807.01 Order Now
200 X $4.449 $889.80 $22.25 $912.05 Order Now
250 X $4.449 $1112.25 $27.81 $1140.06 Order Now
275 X $4.449 $1223.48 $30.59 $1254.07 Order Now
500 X $4.399 $2199.50 $54.99 $2254.49 Order Now

Credit Card Purchase
  • visa
  • mastercard
  • discover
  • amex
  • visaelectron

Tank Size Sub-total Tax Total Buy now
50 X $5.399 $269.95 $6.75 $276.70 Order Now
75 X $4.799 $359.93 $9.00 $368.93 Order Now
100 X $4.649 $464.90 $11.62 $476.52 Order Now
125 X $4.649 $581.13 $14.53 $595.66 Order Now
150 X $4.599 $689.85 $17.25 $707.10 Order Now
175 X $4.599 $804.83 $20.12 $824.95 Order Now
200 X $4.549 $909.80 $22.75 $932.55 Order Now
250 X $4.549 $1137.25 $28.43 $1165.68 Order Now
275 X $4.549 $1250.98 $31.27 $1282.25 Order Now
500 X $4.499 $2249.50 $56.24 $2305.74 Order Now

Order By Dollars

Note: Tax included.